What To Do With Undercooked Brownies?

8 min readMar 4, 2022

What To Do With Undercooked Brownies? We’ve all got a friend or family member who enjoys licking the bowl or spoon after baking. Some people enjoy eating raw cookie dough, but undercooked brownies should not be one of them!

Brownies are a difficult recipe to master, and even the most seasoned and skilled baker may make a mistake when it comes to brownies. A few minutes might be the difference between your brownies being undercooked or overcooked. It’s difficult to know what to do with undercooked brownies. Some brownies are supposed to be gooey, making it even more difficult to determine if you followed the recipe correctly or whether your bake is underdone.

What To Do With Undercooked Brownies

If you created a batch of undercooked brownies and only now realized they were undercooked, you’ll need to know how to tell if they’re undercooked or merely sticky. If they are safe to consume or if they should be avoided and discarded.

This article will discuss what to do with undercooked brownies.

Are my brownies overcooked or gooey?

You’ve made your brownies according to the recipe. But when you take the brownies out of the oven, you’re not sure if they’re done. So, how do undercooked brownies appear?

The sight of an undercooked brownie is one of the telltale indications. The top of the brownie dish is the ideal place to start checking if your brownies are undercooked. If there are cracks on the top layer of the brownies, this may indicate that your brownies are cooked in the centre and gooey, rather than undercooked.

Though the top layer of your brownies seems liquid, squishy, or as if the mixture may slightly jiggle if you move the tin, they are undercooked. This wet top indicates that the brownies did not cook correctly in the center of the tray and will require additional time in the oven.

To make matters even more complicated, there are two sorts of brownies that require somewhat different recipes. As a result, their textures will change somewhat.

There are the traditional brownies, which are cooked all the way through and, once set, are extremely firm and thick. There’s also the fudge brownie. Fudge brownies are mushy, crumbly, and readily crumbled. A fudge brownie is more of a treat than a cake. Fudge brownies are inherently softer and moister. So if they appear gooey, it does not imply that they are undercooked.

It makes no difference whether we’re talking about basic or fudge brownies. Any undercooked brownie will be soggy and flavorless.

How to Tell the Difference Between Gooey and Undercooked

We do have some baking tips and tactics to assist you determine if your brownies are gooey or melty, cooked or undercooked.

What To Do With Undercooked Brownies

Texture Evaluation

The first baking tip is to evaluate the texture. This may be accomplished using a knife or a toothpick. This entails inserting a knife or toothpick into the center of the brownie baking pan to determine the texture of the brownie mixture.

If the toothpick or knife comes out clean, your brownies are completely baked. This will result in a rich and firm cake-like traditional brownie.

If the toothpick or knife comes out with a couple of moist crumbs or mixture, the fudge brownie gooey texture has been achieved. It’s preferable to remove the fudge brownies from the oven at this time.

If a toothpick or knife comes out of the mixture moist, the brownies are undercooked and will need to be baked for a longer period of time.

This is an excellent test for catching the brownies before they overcook and determining if they are undercooked. If you’ve taken your brownies out and they’ve already cooled, this test might not work.

Many people prefer toothpicks rather knives for this test because toothpicks are highly sticky and will provide a genuine portrayal of the brownie mixture. The mixture may not adhere as easily to the knife.

Examine the Temperature

Checking the interior temperature is the next baking test to discover if your brownies are undercooked or sticky. A temperature check can determine if the brownies have reached a safe temperature for ingestion. When serving meals at restaurants and other food places, this is frequently a compulsory step. It is advisable to use a cooking thermometer to monitor the interior temperature.

When checking to see whether your brownies have reached a safe temperature, you want them to be between 160 and 220 degrees Fahrenheit. It’s great if your fudge brownies reach 160–170 degrees Fahrenheit while testing the temperature to ensure they’re still gooey.

Once you’ve determined if they’re gooey or undercooked, you can decide whether to consume them or toss them away.

How to Know When Brownies Are Done

The toothpick test and temperature checks are excellent techniques to determine if your brownies are done or undercooked.

It is critical to provide enough time for brownies to set while baking them. Brownies will continue to cook after you remove them from the oven. Allowing the brownies to cool for at least 30–45 minutes after taking them out of the oven allows them to fully set. This is the time to cut the brownies.

Is it possible to rebake undercooked brownies?

So, can undercooked brownies be re-baked? Yes! Undercooked brownies can be re-baked. This way, your mixture will not go to waste, and you will still be able to enjoy your wonderful bake.

Returning brownies to the oven will ensure that they crisp up and complete baking. When you put your undercooked brownies back in the oven, you run the danger of them burning rapidly, so keep an eye on them. Begin by returning them to the oven for small bursts of time. Undercooked brownies may be only a few minutes short of being cooked, but they may also be a few minutes overdone and scorched. Another disadvantage of this procedure is that it may cause your brownies to dry out.

You may also re-bake your undercooked brownies after allowing them to cool for a few hours. Place the brownies back on a baking sheet and return them to the oven at 200 degrees F. If you set your oven to a high temperature, you risk blasting your brownies and scorching the edges. Brownies cook from the outside in, thus it’s critical not to overcook your brownies. Alternatively, you may wind up with undercooked brownies with charred edges and a dry texture.

What Is the Best Way to Restore Undercooked Brownies?

There are several methods for repairing undercooked brownies, as well as methods for repairing undercooked brownies that have cooled.

Use Additional Ingredients

Some of the ways for repairing undercooked brownies may result in dryness. This may have to be tolerated, and it may be disguised by serving with other components such as chocolate sauce, ice cream, and cream. These components will absorb into the brownies, masking their dryness. If you don’t like the thought of dried edges, you can easily clip them off and only serve the brownie baking tray’s core parts.

When putting your undercooked brownies back into the oven, cover them with tin foil to keep them from burning.

Utilize a Microwave

Undercooked brownies may be repaired in the microwave. This procedure is quick and simple, and it works!

Individual slices of brownies should be microwaved for 30–40 seconds at a time. This ensures that all portions of the brownies have reached a safe temperature. Microwaves are notorious for not doing a good job of evenly heating things. It will be easier if the brownies are cut into smaller pieces. However, unlike an oven, a microwave will cook the brownies from the inside out, making them less prone to burn. Microwaving brownies keeps them moist and prevents dry edges.

Make use of a refrigerator.

Another way to repair undercooked brownies is to store them in the refrigerator. When fudge brownies are too gooey, use this approach. This approach eliminates the need to cook the brownies for an extended period of time.

If the brownies appear to be excessively gooey and hazardous to consume, cook them for a longer period of time rather than utilizing this approach. Using the refrigerator to save your undercooked brownies may harden them, but will not bring the ingredients to a safe eating level and will not cook the eggs and flour for any longer.

Refrigerate the brownies for up to one and a half hours. The brownies will be chewy rather than gooey as a result of this.

Undercooked brownies can also be fixed by freezing them. This will thoroughly solidify and harden up the brownies. This approach, like the fridge method, will not cook the brownies, so only use it if you believe the brownies are safe to consume.

Is it OK to eat undercooked brownies?

No, we don’t think they’re safe to consume. This is due to the inclusion of egg and wheat in the brownie batter.

Salmonella, a bacterium that causes terrible food poisoning, may be found in raw eggs. Uncooked flour may contain microorganisms that might make you sick. This bacteria can not only cause food poisoning, but it can also produce symptoms such as fever. To be safe to eat, flour must be cooked to 160 degrees Fahrenheit.

If you ate undercooked brownies, don’t be alarmed; food illness from undercooked poultry and seafood is more prevalent.

When Pregnant, Don’t Eat Undercooked Brownies

If you are pregnant, it is advised to avoid eating undercooked brownies. Consuming them might expose you to E. Coli or salmonella. These may cause you and your baby to become ill.

Avoid eating undercooked brownies.

Tricks like the toothpick test and temperature check might help you determine if your brownies are overcooked. If they aren’t entirely cooked, you can use an oven, microwave, fridge, or freezer to repair them. If possible, avoid eating undercooked brownies because they are dangerous to your health and do not taste as wonderful as properly cooked ones.

FAQs

Is it okay if the middle of the brownies is gooey?

When preparing fudge brownies, gooey in the centre is OK and even preferred. Don’t be alarmed if your brownies are mushy in the centre. To reassure yourself, simply check for clues that indicate whether your brownies are undercooked or cooked.

In general, you don’t want your brownies to be uncooked in the centre of the tray, so cook them for a little longer.

Should Brownies Have a Gooey Center?

Yes, if you’re making fudge brownies. And they’re delectable!

Fudge brownies might lose their gooey middle if they are cooked for three minutes too long. However, if Fudge brownies are undercooked by three minutes, they might taste awful.

If this is your first time booking brownies, it may be best to start with a basic brownie that is thick and more cake-like.

Is it OK to eat slightly undercooked brownies?

Brownies should be safe to consume if they are merely undercooked by a minute or so and are made with pasteurized eggs. You want to strive for an interior temperature of 160 degrees Fahrenheit for anything containing eggs. They will be safe to consume after they reach this internal temperature.

Is it possible to become sick from eating undercooked brownies?

Because of the egg used in their preparation, undercooked brownies can make you sick. Salmonella, which may cause food illness, can be found in raw eggs. It’s advised to avoid eating undercooked brownies because they don’t taste good and pose significant health hazards.